organic certification

[Robert Dixon <rdixon@cyberstation.net>]

       So many issues to discuss, the cost of certification, is the system
too bureaucratic, should farmers have to pay for it all, does certification
serve any purpose, what is a small farm and should they be excluded from
the need for certification.
       Sal looks at certification as a useless cost since he gets no
benefits from it, he calls it an unfair tax that penalizes him for trying
to farm in a way that does not hurt the environment. I see the cost of
certification as insurance. It tries to ensure that people do not make
false claims, that a system based on trust is safeguarded and that everyone
can back up their claims in a way that would stand up in court.
       I spend a lot of money buying certified organic food and I do not
trust claims of natural or made without chemicals or hormone free etc. etc.
This is not because farmers are trying to cheat the system but rather after
twenty years working in agriculture and five years as an organic inspector,
I see that people mean different things when they say certain words.
Certification helps clear up what exactly is meant by the word organic.
       Costs to small farmers are an issue that certifiers and inspectors
are sensitive about. Most inspectors work at other jobs and so there is
some flexibility when negotiating a price with a particular grower. Perhaps
retailers and processors would give up some of their profits or a check off
could be set up where a few cents of consumers money could go towards the
certification process. Even a tiny fraction of the billions spent by
consumers in the USA would help with certification costs.
       If you exclude organic famers with $50,000. in sales that would take
out most organic growers in the USA. According to the 1993 survey of
organic producers done by the Organic Farming Research Foundation, the
median gross farm income from sales of organic food was between $15, 000
and $30,000. Perhaps things have changed in the last 5 years but most
organic farms are small, family run operations that still need off farm
income ( does someone have more recent facts? ).
       Who likes to fill out forms?!!! Sometimes it seems that is all we
inspectors do. How many farms do we go to where the forms are done
according to the letter of the regulations? Not very many. It takes time to
go through them, verify an audit trail etc. etc. Sal may feel this is a
waste of time but doing that is part of safeguarding the system. Like
insurance you do not think about it untill it is needed. If the paperwork
will not stand up in court then what good is it? Each inspection could hurt
the integrity of the whole system if not done correctly. It does not matter
unti